FBI Sting Uncovers RansomwareHelp's Deceptive Practices
The chief technology officer and co-founder of RansomwareHelp, a Florida-based company that operated for six years, has been indicted on wire fraud charges following an FBI sting operation. The indictment, returned in Rhode Island this week, alleges that 52-year-old Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar of Miami and Medellin, Colombia, routinely paid ransomware groups for decryption keys while marketing the company's services as proprietary cryptographic recovery that never involved ransom payments.
According to court documents, RansomwareHelp's website claimed the company used "advanced cryptographic tools" to restore 100 percent of data, servers, and systems to their original format. The site boasted a "success rate of over 99%," over 28 years of experience, and a team of 80 experts in cryptography, cybersecurity, forensic analysis, and reverse engineering. Most prominently, the website declared: "We never promote, intermediate or pay ransom to threat actors on behalf of our clients."
How the FBI Sting Operation Worked
The government's indictment details an elaborate sting in which FBI agents posed as both a ransomware victim company and a fictitious ransomware group. Investigators contacted RansomwareHelp pretending to be victims of a cyberattack, supplying a phony ransomware note and stating they did not wish to pay a ransom.
RansomwareHelp responded by reiterating its policy against negotiating with or making payments to threat actors. However, Palacio allegedly soon contacted the fake ransomware group operated by the FBI and requested the lowest possible price for a decryptor. FBI investigators quoted a price of 0.2 bitcoin, approximately $13,000 at the time.
Within 48 hours, Palacio reportedly told the agents posing as the victim company that a diagnostic assessment was successful and quoted a decryption cost of $13,260. The following day, Palacio messaged the fictitious ransomware group asking to reduce the ransom demand to $4,000 for the decryption tool. The agreed price was around $6,000 in bitcoin, yet Palacio charged the fake victim firm $16,010 — including a $2,750 diagnostic fee and the full $13,260 decryption fee.
Real-World Victim: Accounting Firm Targeted by Lockbit
Paul Ihme, co-founder of security firm Soteria, provided KrebsOnSecurity with details of a 2024 case involving a small accounting firm hit by Lockbit ransomware. The firm had paid RansomwareHelp a diagnostic fee to recover locked company and client data.
RansomwareHelp sent a proposal with a recovery price of $438,880, claiming the cost covered "professional configuration of forensic servers," "expert engineering hours of programming to configure decryption algorithms," and "eight (6-hour processing cycles) related to the decryption process." The proposal stated the recovery involved reverse engineering the ransomware encryption using "510 preconfigured forensic servers of the maximum quantitative capacity located in different parts of the world" and that programmers would "inject randomly the encryption codes extracted during the forensic and cryptographic analysis using brute force processes."
Suspicious Remote Access Demands
Ihme noted that RansomwareHelp insisted on unrestricted remote access to the victim's network via AnyDesk remote desktop software. Ihme believes this access was used to delete ransomware notes left by attackers across the victim's network. A typical ransomware note contains the threat group's identity, demands, and contact information — often an email or darknet chat link — and attackers typically leave copies on every compromised system.
A review of the accounting firm's network found only one copy of the ransom note, recovered from a backup snapshot on a single infected computer. When Ihme's team connected to the Lockbit chat server using the provided user ID, they discovered someone had already been negotiating with the extortionists for several days.
Chat Logs Reveal Secret Negotiations
Screenshots of conversations between RansomwareHelp and Lockbit show the company pleading with the ransomware group not to reveal to the victim that negotiations were underway. Lockbit grew frustrated with the prolonged discussions, threatening to increase the ransom demand by $100,000 for each additional day of delay.
Even after it became clear a new negotiator was engaging with Lockbit on the victim's behalf, RansomwareHelp continued messaging the group: "I tell you something, that person who is negotiating with you for the other chat is damaging the whole process. Please do not change the price. I am doing my best to achieve it."
Ultimately, the accounting firm followed Ihme's advice and engaged a more established security firm, which negotiated a payment to Lockbit at half the amount RansomwareHelp had quoted. The victim told Ihme: "If we don't get this data back, our business is over."
Technical Claims Deemed Farcical by Experts
Ihme stated that RansomwareHelp primarily targeted small to medium-sized businesses lacking technical expertise. Many claims in the company's proposals are "patently farcical," he said. For example, the proposal to the accounting firm claimed the ability to break six types of encryption but then listed irrelevant password hashing algorithms like SHA-256.
"If it were really true these guys could decrypt any ransomware out there, this guy would be a billionaire," Ihme remarked. "They were going after people who don't have any technical knowledge, are desperate, and don't have anyone advising them about how any of this stuff works."
Pattern of Prosecutions Targeting Fraudulent Recovery Firms
The case against Palacio is the latest in a series of Department of Justice prosecutions against security firms accused of conspiring with fraudsters to defraud ransomware victims.
- In early October 2026, the government charged 54-year-old Edward Dubrovsky, an executive at Canadian cybersecurity firm Cybersteward, with cyber extortion and conspiracy charges. The case remains sealed.
- Around the same time, MonsterCloud CEO Zohar Pinhasi, 50, was charged with wire fraud and conspiracy for allegedly charging customers to remediate ransomware attacks while secretly paying hackers. Charging documents allege Pinhasi paid ransomware groups $8 million while charging customers $19 million.
- In July 2026, Angelo Martino, a 41-year-old ransomware negotiator from Land O'Lakes, Florida, was sentenced to 70 months in prison for conspiring with the Blackcat/ALPHV ransomware group. The DoJ found Martino provided confidential information about his employer's clients' negotiating positions to help the ransomware actors maximize ransom payments.
These cases highlight a growing pattern of companies exploiting desperate ransomware victims by falsely claiming proprietary decryption capabilities while secretly facilitating ransom payments for profit.
Source: Krebs on Security